Rugby, baby, yeah! Makes me randy, lol yeah, if you could do AT&T and BYOP your options would be opened wider than a cheerleaders legs at the big game(referring to the hyped up jumping split you pervs, now get your head out of the gutter lol)...
Check out Green Cells www.usedcellphoneshop.com/
they have great deals on used phones, but their selection is ever changing as it's a trade-in/reused based site... they also do trade-in discounts and recycling, coupon codes can be found online and they offer repeat customer discounts I think also, and a warranty, can't remember if its 30, 60, or 90 days though.
Samsung Galaxy Express is also a great pick if you find one used, a friend of mine picked one up from Green Cells in like new condition for $115 with a coupon code, you get 4g LTE service on it with ST's AT&T BYOP sim(where available when on AT&T's network)... 1.2GHz dual core, like 689 or more available RAM I can't remember exactly, I just glanced over the storage and RAM on it when he got it. (I would assume it's 1GB before the OS sucks some up) just under 5GB available storage, I wouldn't exactly call it break proof, but I'm sure you could otterbox it and that would be just as good... they are like $250 brand new, it's an ATT Go!Phone and runs 4.1.2 Jelly Bean... it's the second phone he bought from Green Cells with no issues.
or you could get yourself a Google Nexus 4, which, I believe is only like $230 new from google play store(on pc) and is completely bloat free and not carrier locked since it is a native Nexus.
Now if you go with Net10 they have a much bigger selection of phones than their StraightTalk sister and it might be worth it since you are gonna have multiple phones, Net10 offers family plan prepaid...
So, inshort I wouldn't necessarily recommend any StraightTalk phone as long as there is BYOP lol, you can generally get more phone for your money on the used market... but ST is getting better phones in now from what I can tell so that may not necessarily hold true now.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I827 using Xparent Skyblue Tapatalk 2